Social Media on Trial: 

Author avatar

Carolanne Bamford-Beattie

|

Media trial

What the Addiction Lawsuits Mean for Parents

In Summary:

  • A landmark U.S. trial is putting social media companies under scrutiny, with families arguing platforms are designed to keep young users hooked and contribute to mental health challenges.
  • Research shows excessive and comparison-driven use can harm wellbeing, particularly for teens, whose developing brains are more vulnerable to reward loops, social validation, and sleep disruption.
  • The outcome could reshape platform safety standards, but parents still play the most important role in guiding healthy digital habits.
  • Families can reduce risks now by setting boundaries, encouraging mindful use, prioritising sleep, and teaching children how social media algorithms influence what they see.

In early 2026, a landmark legal battle began in the United States that could reshape the future of social media and how children use it.

Families, schools, and young people are taking some of the world’s biggest tech companies to court, arguing that platforms were deliberately designed to be addictive and harmful to young users.

The case is being closely watched worldwide because it raises urgent questions for parents: 

Can social media be addictive and are platforms really designed to keep kids hooked?

Let’s unpack what’s happening and why it matters.

What is the Social Media Trial about?

The current trial in Los Angeles is the first of its kind. More than 1,600 plaintiffs including families, teens, and school districts accuse major platforms such as Meta (Instagram and Facebook), TikTok, Snapchat, and YouTube of intentionally designing addictive systems that harm children’s mental health.

The lead case involves a young woman who says she developed severe mental health struggles after becoming addicted to social media at a young age.

This case is considered a “bellwether trial”, meaning its outcome could influence thousands of similar lawsuits already filed. And, if the plaintiffs succeed, the result could:

  • Force design changes to social platforms
  • Set new youth safety standards
  • Increase legal accountability for tech companies
  • Open the door to further lawsuits

To give some context through comparison, some legal experts are speaking about the case as akin to lawsuits against tobacco companies in the 1990s. 

At the heart of the social media addiction lawsuit is a bold accusation: that platforms intentionally use psychological design techniques to keep users engaged.

The lawsuit argues companies use features such as…

  • Infinite scroll
  • Autoplay videos
  • Algorithmic recommendations
  • Push notifications
  • Personalized feeds

…are all designed to maximize engagement and advertising revenue.

Critics say these features encourage compulsive use and exploit reward systems in the brain that are similar to how slot machines or gambling mechanics work.

Social Media Addiction Lawsuits: TikTok and Snapchat Settlements

TikTok and Snapchat settled with the lead plaintiff shortly before trial, though the terms were not disclosed. Meta and YouTube continue to fight the case in court.

Settlements do not necessarily indicate wrongdoing, but they allow companies to avoid releasing internal documents or undergoing testimony.

What Tech Companies Say in their Defense

Tech companies strongly deny the claims with their key arguments including:

  • Social media is not inherently harmful
  • Mental health challenges have multiple causes
  • Users control how they use platforms
  • Companies have introduced safety features and parental controls

In particular, Meta has stated social media should not be singled out as the sole cause of teen mental health struggles.

This reflects a broader scientific debate about whether social media causes harm, or whether vulnerable users are more affected.

What Does the Research say? Is Social Media Actually Addictive?

One of the most contested aspects of the trial is the use of the word “addiction.” Some experts prefer the term “problematic use” rather than addiction.

Social media addiction research suggests social media can trigger brain activity patterns similar to gambling, but it lacks the physical withdrawal symptoms associated with substance addiction.

However, many health professionals agree that excessive use can harm well-being, especially in developing adolescent brains.

Signs of Problematic Social Media Use

Research links heavy use social media use with a variety of social, emotional and physical symptoms, including:

  • Anxiety and depression
  • Sleep disruption
  • Low self-esteem
  • Body image concerns
  • Reduced attention span
  • Increased loneliness

Not every child is affected equally, but the risk rises with time spent and type of use.

Why Teens May be Especially Vulnerable

Adolescence is a critical period for brain development and social platforms are uniquely powerful during this stage because they tap into:

1. Reward sensitivity

Teen brains are more responsive to rewards, including likes, shares, and comments.

2. Social belonging

Peer approval becomes extremely important during adolescence.

3. Identity formation

Teens experiment with self-image and social status online.

4. Emotional regulation

Young users are still learning how to manage strong emotions.

When platforms amplify comparison, validation loops, and viral trends, the psychological impact can intensify.

How Algorithms Keep Kids Hooked

One of the least understood aspects of social media is how algorithms decide what content children see. Platforms track viewing time, likes, pauses, and interactions to predict what will keep users engaged. Over time, this creates a highly personalized feed designed to hold attention.

For young users, this can mean being shown increasingly extreme or emotionally charged content because strong reactions drive engagement. A child who watches one dieting video may quickly see more body-image content. A teen who pauses on dramatic news clips may be served more distressing material.

This isn’t necessarily intentional harm, but it is a system optimized for engagement.

Teaching children how algorithms work helps them understand that what appears in their feed isn’t a neutral reflection of reality.

The Social Media Trial and Links to Mental Health Concerns

Plaintiffs in the trial argue platform use contributed to depression, eating disorders, self-harm, and suicide among young users.

While causation remains debated, researchers increasingly recognize connections between heavy social media use and declining mental well-being.

Importantly, risk is highest when use includes:

  • Passive scrolling
  • Comparison-driven content
  • Cyberbullying exposure
  • Late-night usage

By contrast, active communication with friends can have positive effects.

A Global Push for Regulation

The trial reflects growing worldwide concern about youth social media use.

Countries like the UK are exploring new rules, including:

  • Age restrictions
  • Design regulations
  • Safety requirements
  • Algorithm transparency

Australia has already banned social media accounts for children under 16.

Meanwhile, the EU has warned TikTok over design features that may promote compulsive use.

This global momentum suggests the conversation is shifting from screen time to platform responsibility.

What Social Media Addiction Research Tells Us:

Although research is ongoing, several key findings are widely accepted:

1. Not all use is harmful

The effects depend on duration, content, and individual vulnerability.

2. Algorithms amplify engagement

Recommendation systems prioritize emotionally stimulating content.

3. Sleep disruption is a major factor

Nighttime device use strongly correlates with mental health challenges.

4. Social comparison increases risk

Exposure to idealized images can harm self-esteem.

5. Younger users are more vulnerable

Early exposure increases risk of problematic habits.

Researchers continue to study long-term impacts, but there is broad agreement that moderation and guidance are essential.

What do the Current Social Media Trials Mean for Parents?

Regardless of how the trial ends, one message is clear: parents cannot rely on platforms alone to protect children.

Tech companies may improve safety features, but family guidance remains the most powerful protective factor. Here’s what parents can do now.

7 Practical Steps to Protect your Child Online

Social media isn’t going anywhere, and teens face significant pressure to be online from peers and the demands of modern life. For most families, outright bans won’t work, so conversations and boundaries are crucial to keep kids safe. 


1. Start conversations early

Talk openly about social media before problems arise.

2. Delay access when possible

Later adoption is linked to healthier habits.

3. Set device-free sleep routines

Removing phones from bedrooms improves sleep and mood.

4. Focus on quality, not just time

Encourage creative and social uses rather than passive scrolling.

5. Teach critical thinking

Help children understand algorithms, filters, and online comparison.

6. Model healthy behavior

Children mirror adult device habits.

7. Use parental controls thoughtful

Tools like Kidslox help set boundaries and monitor usage without constant conflict.

The ultimate goal isn’t to eliminate social media, it’s to teach healthy digital habits.

Encourage children to notice:

  • how they feel after scrolling
  • when they lose track of time
  • what content lifts them up vs. brings them down

The Bigger Question: Who is Responsible?

The social media addiction trial is forcing society to confront a difficult question:

Should responsibility rest with families, users, or tech companies?

The likely answer is: all three.

  • Platforms design the experience
  • Governments regulate safety
  • Parents guide usage

The ongoing social media trial marks a turning point in how the world views technology, childhood, and mental health.

Whether or not courts determine that platforms are legally responsible, the evidence is clear:

Children need guidance, boundaries, and digital resilience skills to thrive online.

Social media isn’t going away, but with the right support, kids can learn to use it safely, confidently, and in balance with real life.